As a pediatrician and mother, if you ask me how I feel about television for my 12 month old daughter, all I can say is no thanks. Not now, anyway. That opinion is supported by the American Academy's Policy statement of television viewing in kids under 2 years. In a nutshell, no TV before age 2.
When I mention this at routine well child visits, many parents tell me that they allow their infants to watch 30 minutes to 1 hour day. They go on to say that they use only what they call "educational DVDs", like the popular Baby Einstein. Most parents, assume that these DVDs are actually educational and help kids learn. To be sure, Baby Einstein was created by a single individual, and as far as I understand has no scientific research to prove educational value.
Until now, it has been challenging for me to convince overwhelmed parents that avoiding the television before 2 years is best. I often explain that talking and singing to your child is better than the 30 minutes of television. Most parents understand my thoughts, but they explain life gets in the way: laundry, dinner, dishes etc. And so, visit after visit, parents tell me that their kids get "educational time" with the tube.
But most pediatricians know, intuitively that TV is not helpful for a child's growth. The March 2009 Pediatrics journal describes a study on the relationship between infants, TV and learning. The study concludes that for kids under 3, television does not assist in learning.
The researchers came to that conclusion by studying children from birth to 3 years. They tracked how much time a child spent watching TV from birth until 2 and at age 3 tested cognitive outcomes. What they found was, that kids who watched television did not have increased language and visual skills.
But what I find fascinating is that Baby Einstein uses this same study in the March 2009 journal of pediatrics on its website as a reason to explain why television is not bad for your child. I was stunned when a blog writer for the NY times writes about this same study and says "But here’s what else the study showed: contrary to what the researchers had expected to find, those babies were not WORSE off, either."
I don't know how anyone can draw that conclusion considering that many previous studies have linked children watching television to ADHD, obesity, violent behaviour, and decreased language and motor skills. Other studies have linked television with irregular sleep patterns in kids less than 2. Early television exposure has also been linked to hyperactivity. An important concept to consider when placing your infant in front of the tube. But, again when you read the baby Einstein websites, they handpick only a few studies from the vast research and then suggest that there is no harm.
The study in this months' pediatric journal did have some shortcomings. The researchers did not address exactly what the infants were watching. It also measure outcomes at age 3, and it is possible that this may be too early to test for improvement or detriments in visual and cognitive skills. An earlier study, tested kids at age 6 and determined that watching TV did lead to lower cognitive outcomes. Despite that the study seems to have many strengths. However, I do not interpret the study to suggest that television is not at all detrimental to a child's health.
That said, I, like many of my parents, am tempted to reach out and place my little girl in front of the TV. So far we have avoided putting her in front of the television. (And I do understand that if I had multiple children, it would be much harder to avoid television for the younger child.) I don't believe that my daughter will never watch television. Remember, I live and breathe media. But, I am going to hold out for as long as I can, hopefully until she is 3 years old.
When she does start watching television, it will be limited as the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends. My goal will be to be particular about what she watches, watch television with her, and talk her to about what she is watching. This will help ensure she gets the messages I want her to get.
In the mean time, I will be spending time with my daughter. The developmental studies have proven that talking, singing and spending time with your child, does greatly assist in your child's cognitive development.
Get outside and get moving.
Build something
